The first 300 real-time traveler safety scores for Cancun, Punta Cana, and Cabo have been removed

Share article

If you listen to the 24-hour news, the Mexican Caribbean is a danger zone. If you listen to the State Department, you need to take “extra vigilance” or reconsider travel altogether.

But what if we listened to the voices of actual Americans on the beach right now? That’s a completely different story.

Over the past 48 hours, Travel Off Path has been running the world’s first real-time Traveler Safety Index. We did not consult government analysts in Washington, DC. We asked the people who really matter: travelers on the ground.

The first 300 verified reports will be officially registered.

From downtown Cancun to the luxurious corridors of Los Cabos to the beaches of Punta Cana, the data paints a picture that defies the headlines. While the advisory screams “red flag,” people sitting in pool chairs are voting “green light.”

Here’s a real-time safety breakdown for three of North America’s most popular destinations. Reported by travelers who have actually seen the place.

You can also vote at the bottom of the article.

1. Los Cabos: “Untouchable” Bubble (Score: 90/100)

On the Pacific side, Los Cabos takes the top spot as Mexico’s most rated destination. User feedback explains why. “I feel isolated.”

While other destinations have chaotic energies, reports from Cabo describe a “bubble effect.” Travelers in the Marina and Medano Beach areas report feeling more entertained than watched.

The difference here is the atmosphere. While other spots are buzzing with party tourism (and the petty scams that come with it), Cabo feels calmer and more “untouchable.” The “fear factor” that the news is trying to sell does not exist within the resort corridors.

2. Punta Cana: A “frictionless” vacation (Score: 90/100)

Punta Cana, often overshadowed by its Mexican rivals, has quietly forged ties with Cabo to ensure its security, but it feels different. There’s no friction.

To the all-encompassing crowd, “danger” feels non-existent. Bavaro and Cap Cana report that there is almost no interaction with the outside world. Stress disappears when you enter the resort.

Although the United States generally advises caution in disaster preparedness, local travelers report vacation experiences that feel completely unrelated to local security issues. It’s pure autopilot.

3. Cancun: Safe, but use your wallet wisely (Score: 89/100)

Although Cancun remains the most popular destination, certain factors rank it third on the safety list, according to travelers.

Although travelers report feeling physically safe, the data shows specific frustrations with high-pressure sales tactics. The “scams” flagged by your system are probably classic traps. Free tequila and free transportation designed to lure you into timeshare presentations. This, combined with aggressive taxi pricing, creates a real point of friction. You are not looking behind you for danger. You are looking at your wallet.

Atmosphere: Lively, bustling beach, no physical threats. Be prepared to say “no” to freebies.

Check the live index

These three destinations are just the beginning. The Traveler Safety Index currently tracks raw sentiment in the Caribbean, Mexico, and around the world.

Use the interactive tools below to search for specific destinations, compare safety scores, and submit your own reports to the network.

are we wrong?

The gap between “official warnings” and “traveler reality” has never been wider. However, feelings quickly change. A single event can completely change the atmosphere in minutes.

We are not asking for your opinion. We want your reality. Whether you’re in Mexico, the Caribbean, or anywhere in the world right now, don’t let politicians speak for you. Vote using the widget above.